In partnership with

AI for Real Life Newsletter

Google Imagen 4 vs. ChatGPT Image Generator: The Showdown Begins

You’ve probably seen the hype. Google just released Imagen 4, and it’s a real contender in the AI image game. Naturally, I had to throw it into the ring with ChatGPT’s image generator and see how they compare.

I’ve been testing both side-by-side with everything from creative ads to cinematic character posters. What I found is that it’s not so much about which one is better overall. It’s more about how you like to work. Let’s break it down in plain terms: speed, image quality, text handling, workflow experience, and real-world prompts you can try for yourself.

⚡ Speed

First up, speed. And Imagen 4 is fast. For example, prompts that take ChatGPT 40–60 seconds to render are popping out of Imagen 4 in just 5–10 seconds. That kind of difference adds up quickly when you’re generating a lot of visuals.

While ChatGPT generates incredibly high-quality images, it takes a little longer, especially on highly detailed prompts. Imagen 4 delivers results quickly, making it ideal for deadlines or high-volume content creation.

Speed Winner: Imagen 4

🎨 Image Quality & Detail

This one’s close, and both tools are capable of creating beautiful, photorealistic, highly stylized images. I tested them with the same prompts, and each gave me slightly different interpretations, but both nailed the tone and clarity I was aiming for.

• ChatGPT gives you more flexibility in the moment. You can easily go back and tweak your prompt or refine details in conversation.

• Imagen 4 tends to get it right in one shot. The visuals are vivid, colors pop, and details are sharp.

Quality Winner: It’s a tie. Different strengths, equally strong results.

🔤 Text Inside Images

This one might surprise people. Everyone’s saying Imagen 4 handles text inside images better, and it is very good. But I’ll be honest—ChatGPT has done really well for me, too.

In all my tests so far, both tools have rendered clean, readable text. I haven't seen major errors from either. They each have a distinct design style, so depending on the vibe you want, one might suit your project better. But when it comes to getting the text to actually appear correctly, both are doing a solid job.

This is something I’ll keep testing, but for now…

Text Rendering: Calling it a tie. You be the judge. I’m sharing all my side-by-side examples so you can compare for yourself.

🧠 Workflow Experience

• ChatGPT feels like you’re building something with a creative partner. It’s conversational, intuitive, and lets you adjust ideas as you go.

• Imagen 4 is clean, fast, and straight to the point. No fluff. It’s like hiring a laser-focused designer who always understands your brief.

Workflow Winner: Depends on your style. I use both—ChatGPT when I want to co-create, Imagen 4 when I want instant polish.

📸 Prompt Gallery: Try These Yourself

These are the exact prompts I used for this test. You’ve already seen the visuals in my video (watch here), now try them with your favorite generator and see what you get:

1. Lightbulb Moment Ad

A cinematic square poster: a person in a black turtleneck with an incandescent lightbulb for a head. Inside the bulb, scrolling holographic AI prompts glow in pale blue. Deep charcoal background with faint circuit patterns. Top text: "THIS IS YOUR SIGN." Center text: "SUBSCRIBE TO THE AI FOR REAL LIFE NEWSLETTER. Real tools. Real impact. No hype." Bottom: "Link’s on my profile." Warm amber and cool blue lighting, shallow depth of field.

2. The Return of Google (Movie Poster)

A cinematic action-movie poster featuring a futuristic superhero standoff between two AI titans: Google vs. ChatGPT. The central figure is a medium-brown-skinned Black man in a sleek, Black Panther-inspired supersuit with glowing AI circuitry. He’s wearing a plain black baseball cap, no glasses. He holds a glowing digital orb, pulsing with data lines. Background shows a massive explosion, debris flying, a cracked Google logo, and a dark silhouette of ChatGPT’s swirl logo in the distance. Title text: “THE RETURN OF GOOGLE.” Subtitle: “Here to conquer ChatGPT.” Top tagline: “The long-awaited battle has begun.” Dramatic color grading with steel blue, orange highlights, and neon glitch effects.

3. Energy Drink Product Mockup

A photorealistic close-up of a matte aluminum can on a concrete surface. The can reads “AI for Real Life ENERGY DRINK” in bold, modern black text on a white label. Below: “L-Theanine + Lion’s Mane | 45mg Natural Caffeine.” Minimalist studio lighting. In the background, blurred laptop, pencil holder, and color swatches. Shot flat, with soft natural shadows. Clean, product-photography aesthetic.

4. Restaurant Menu POV

A cinematic over-the-shoulder POV of a young woman’s hand holding a paper menu in a cozy, candlelit Italian trattoria. Medium-brown skin, gold rings, blush-pink manicure. On the table: a linen tablecloth, half-full wine glass, and flickering candle. Menu is off-white textured paper with serif fonts. Visible menu text:
Antipasti  
– Burrata with Roasted Peppers – $12  
– Truffle Arancini – $10  
Primi  
– Tagliatelle al Tartufo – $22  
– Linguine alle Vongole – $21  
Secondi  
– Pollo al Marsala – $25  
Dolci  
– Tiramisu – $9

🗣 Final Thoughts

Imagen 4 and ChatGPT are both incredibly powerful image tools. They have different strengths, but neither one is clearly better. What matters most is how you work and what you’re creating.

Here’s what I want you to try next:

Use the prompts above, run your own comparisons, and tell me what you find. I’ll be featuring your results in next week’s issue.

And if you're not subscribed yet, what are you doing?

Come get the full breakdowns, exclusive prompt packs, and hands-on insight to improve your AI workflows. Plus, get first-look tests of new tools every single week.

Until next time!

One of the best ways to support us is to click on the link below and check out this other newsletter that you may enjoy. Thanks for supporting our Journey!

• Ai For Real Life

Find out why 1M+ professionals read Superhuman AI daily.

In 2 years you will be working for AI

Or an AI will be working for you

Here's how you can future-proof yourself:

1. Join the Superhuman AI newsletter – read by 1M+ people at top companies

2. Master AI tools, tutorials, and news in just 3 minutes a day

3. Become 10X more productive using AI

Join 1,000,000+ pros at companies like Google, Meta, and Amazon that are using AI to get ahead.

Sign up and start learning AI